Comments on: Merrie Melodies: The Early Worm Gets The Bird http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird Wed, 09 Nov 2011 03:17:16 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v= By: john870 http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-415 john870 Sat, 05 Jul 2008 21:03:19 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-415 This is a great little cartoon. Why is everything about race? I like this cartton and i see nothing about putting down any one. Even black americans needed work back in the hard days of america. Even if they could only use they're voices. My step dad was an black american. And i loved this ol fart he was the best dad. We werent raised to hat and even he loved the little cartoons. So please exsplain the race thingy in this cartoon. Becouse ima missing it. please move on folks or nothing will ever change. This is a great little cartoon. Why is everything about race?
I like this cartton and i see nothing about putting down any one.
Even black americans needed work back in the hard days of america. Even if they could only use they’re voices.
My step dad was an black american. And i loved this ol fart he was the best dad.
We werent raised to hat and even he loved the little cartoons.
So please exsplain the race thingy in this cartoon. Becouse ima missing it.
please move on folks or nothing will ever change.

]]> By: AmirFahzad http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-414 AmirFahzad Wed, 26 Sep 2007 18:19:00 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-414 This cartoon was made at a time when blackface comedy was standard fare in America. Did this broad stereotyping represent black folks accurately? Of course not! Did it offend blacks at the time? Most likely it did, but blacks then were not a political force and were powerless to do anything about it. These old "racist" cartoons were not malicious in their intent, but just perpetuated the old-style blackface characters and comedy popularized by minstrel shows, Al Jolson, Amos & Andy, etc. They're just a snapshot of the society that made them. This cartoon was made at a time when blackface comedy was standard fare in America. Did this broad stereotyping represent black folks accurately? Of course not! Did it offend blacks at the time? Most likely it did, but blacks then were not a political force and were powerless to do anything about it.

These old “racist” cartoons were not malicious in their intent, but just perpetuated the old-style blackface characters and comedy popularized by minstrel shows, Al Jolson, Amos & Andy, etc. They’re just a snapshot of the society that made them.

]]> By: haft98brant http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-413 haft98brant Sat, 22 Sep 2007 07:10:29 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-413 Ike many, he tries to revise history by pointing out the overt racism in the cartoon. No kidding. Unfortunately, your attempts to boost your own worth by pointing out the foibles of those who lived before yo is an empty gesture. YOu seem to beleive that YOU would have done better had you lived in 1939; I doubt it. Clown. Ike many, he tries to revise history by pointing out the overt racism in the cartoon. No kidding.
Unfortunately, your attempts to boost your own worth by pointing out the foibles of those who lived before yo is an empty gesture. YOu seem to beleive that YOU would have done better had you lived in 1939; I doubt it. Clown.

]]> By: UmOmar http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-412 UmOmar Wed, 19 Sep 2007 17:30:18 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-412 The entertainment value for me and my children is really overshadowed by the racism depicted. The birds are drawn with stereotypical features with the plot and dialogue no more than a "Black Face" routine of the minstrels. Would I feel comfortable having this cartoon playing on my computer screen in an airport? Ask yourself that. Now, it does have a high educational value for older children who have a concept in place about the history of race relations in America, civil rights, and the many successes of African-Americans. A parent could explain the negative aspects to stereotyping racial groups and could even draw parellels between the past for African-Americans and the present with Arab-Americans. The entertainment value for me and my children is really overshadowed by the racism depicted. The birds are drawn with stereotypical features with the plot and dialogue no more than a “Black Face” routine of the minstrels. Would I feel comfortable having this cartoon playing on my computer screen in an airport? Ask yourself that.

Now, it does have a high educational value for older children who have a concept in place about the history of race relations in America, civil rights, and the many successes of African-Americans. A parent could explain the negative aspects to stereotyping racial groups and could even draw parellels between the past for African-Americans and the present with Arab-Americans.

]]> By: southerngal@bellsouth.net http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-411 southerngal@bellsouth.net Sat, 16 Dec 2006 08:56:48 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-411 Now this one, I don't really have a problem with, because all of the animals spoke in a broken southern dialect (not just the "Blackbird" family), therefore I don't deem it as being racist. Although it may be a tad bit demeaning to people of the "South", because they don't seem to be very articulate, but in any event, this was one of the cartoons that teaches a lesson, which makes it valuable as well as comical! Go figure the lesson was being taught by a loving, plump, and spiritual black mother ;) . Now this one, I don’t really have a problem with, because all of the animals spoke in a broken southern dialect (not just the “Blackbird” family), therefore I don’t deem it as being racist. Although it may be a tad bit demeaning to people of the “South”, because they don’t seem to be very articulate, but in any event, this was one of the cartoons that teaches a lesson, which makes it valuable as well as comical! Go figure the lesson was being taught by a loving, plump, and spiritual black mother ;) .

]]> By: donotmetimid http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-410 donotmetimid Sun, 10 Dec 2006 18:27:51 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-410 The blackbirds in this cartoon have southern African American accents, but I don't see this as being racist, anymore than Elmer Fud is racist. (He's a white guy that is the butt of jokes.) It's just humor using personification. Perhaps giving blackbirds this accent is appropriate. . . If anything this cartoon helps to break down the wall between the birds and the worm; See it from the other character's (person's) perspective. The blackbirds in this cartoon have southern African American accents, but I don’t see this as being racist, anymore than Elmer Fud is racist. (He’s a white guy that is the butt of jokes.) It’s just humor using personification. Perhaps giving blackbirds this accent is appropriate. . . If anything this cartoon helps to break down the wall between the birds and the worm; See it from the other character’s (person’s) perspective.

]]> By: JAW-MAN http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-409 JAW-MAN Mon, 25 Sep 2006 05:26:55 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-409 ...I would hesitate to place this one among the greatest Warner cartoons ever. Apart from the obvious racial element, this is only a pretty standard entry in the Merrie Melodies series. The quality of this print is great, however. …I would hesitate to place this one among the greatest Warner cartoons ever. Apart from the obvious racial element, this is only a pretty standard entry in the Merrie Melodies series. The quality of this print is great, however.

]]> By: WarnerArt http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-408 WarnerArt Tue, 06 Jun 2006 00:20:06 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-408 You can see actual cels used in the making of this cartoon at www.warnerart.com This Merrie Melodies short was created during a period when the animators at Leon Sclesinger Studios were trying to mimic the cartoons of Disney. By todays standards it's racist and offensive but in 1940 the stereotypes were commonplace and endured by African Americans on a daily basis. While these cartoons are no longer shown as they are politically incorrect, they remain an important part of animation and cultural history. You can see actual cels used in the making of this cartoon at http://www.warnerart.com This Merrie Melodies short was created during a period when the animators at Leon Sclesinger Studios were trying to mimic the cartoons of Disney. By todays standards it’s racist and offensive but in 1940 the stereotypes were commonplace and endured by African Americans on a daily basis. While these cartoons are no longer shown as they are politically incorrect, they remain an important part of animation and cultural history.

]]> By: Spuzz http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-407 Spuzz Mon, 01 May 2006 02:45:46 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-407 There is NOTHING in the world like rediscovering one of your favorite cartoons when you were growing up. Such as the case of Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?The Early Bird Gets The WormÃ?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â? which tells about a young blackbird discovering the joys and pains of hunting for a worm at daybreak. As I said, IÃ?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?ve seen this before.. MANY times, and it sure was fun remembering gags and lines used in this film. Surprisingly enough, I saw this plenty of times in the 1970Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?s, even though this is AWFULLY racist nowadays. But this is sure entertaining stuff! One of my faves! There is NOTHING in the world like rediscovering one of your favorite cartoons when you were growing up. Such as the case of Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?The Early Bird Gets The WormÃ?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â? which tells about a young blackbird discovering the joys and pains of hunting for a worm at daybreak. As I said, IÃ?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?ve seen this before.. MANY times, and it sure was fun remembering gags and lines used in this film. Surprisingly enough, I saw this plenty of times in the 1970Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?Ã?Â?s, even though this is AWFULLY racist nowadays. But this is sure entertaining stuff! One of my faves!

]]> By: samrees http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-406 samrees Mon, 13 Mar 2006 16:27:42 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-406 nothing new. typical chase scenes, with the ole put the victim in the sandwich scene.... many of the ideas must have been taken from other cartoons. lacking in life and any real creativity nothing new. typical chase scenes, with the ole put the victim in the sandwich scene…. many of the ideas must have been taken from other cartoons. lacking in life and any real creativity

]]> By: black_perry http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-405 black_perry Fri, 17 Feb 2006 06:17:40 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-405 Viel Spa�������������������������������� im Karneval! W�������������������������������¼nsch Dir ein sch�������������������������������¶nes We ---I know i'm off-topic--- Viel Spa�������������������������������� im Karneval! W�������������������������������¼nsch Dir ein sch�������������������������������¶nes We

—I know i’m off-topic—

]]> By: sirkutbored http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-404 sirkutbored Wed, 04 Jan 2006 18:36:09 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-404 In a world where the choice of merry christmas and happy holidays starts fights between disparate groups, I guess anyone, anywhere can be offended by anything, but I remember seeing this when I was growing up and maybe it was just me but at 5 years old I guess I just didn't think about racial implications. Being Southern myself, I enjoyed the fact that every character spoke with a southern accent and beyond that never gave it a second thought. Strange how kids will miss the bigger picture that adults who have been jaded will always see. Is it racist? Hardly. Offensive? Not unless you see offensive material everywhere. The bird wants to get the early worm, the worm wants to see what an early bird is and when the bird gets in trouble with an actual predator, who comes to his aid? the worm. The last scene in fact, where the worm is in the bed, would seem to signify that the bird and worm are now close enough friends to overlook the predator and prey aspect. Great moral story and classic warner brothers animation. A must see. In a world where the choice of merry christmas and happy holidays starts fights between disparate groups, I guess anyone, anywhere can be offended by anything, but I remember seeing this when I was growing up and maybe it was just me but at 5 years old I guess I just didn’t think about racial implications. Being Southern myself, I enjoyed the fact that every character spoke with a southern accent and beyond that never gave it a second thought. Strange how kids will miss the bigger picture that adults who have been jaded will always see. Is it racist? Hardly. Offensive? Not unless you see offensive material everywhere. The bird wants to get the early worm, the worm wants to see what an early bird is and when the bird gets in trouble with an actual predator, who comes to his aid? the worm. The last scene in fact, where the worm is in the bed, would seem to signify that the bird and worm are now close enough friends to overlook the predator and prey aspect. Great moral story and classic warner brothers animation. A must see.

]]> By: John-boy http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-403 John-boy Wed, 24 Aug 2005 09:41:12 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-403 This cartoon portrays it's characters as Southern blacks. This in an of itself isn't offensive in the least, in that the charicatures aren't portrayed in a negative fashion. The "mammy" bird is shown to be wise and loving, the adventurous baby bird as being young and impetuous, like most young boys. Besides, the worm is *also* portrayed as a Southern black. But as far as the dialect, all of the characters *including the fox* are simply speaking in a Southern dialect. The plot is well written and portrays both forgiveness (on the part of the worm) and good parenting (on the part of the mother bird.) Historically, all races are charicatured in cartoons, white (*especially* whites!), blacks, Eastern Asians, native Americans, etc. Learn to have a sense of humor and just view this cartoon for what it is... HUMOR and entertainment. Don't be too sensitive. I.e. dont't become somebody who falls for Jerry Seinfeld's "anti-dentite" skit. I enjoyed this cartoon as a child and *still* enjoy it. Overcome a tendency to write this one off as "racist" and simply enjoy it. This cartoon portrays it’s characters as Southern blacks. This in an of itself isn’t offensive in the least, in that the charicatures aren’t portrayed in a negative fashion. The “mammy” bird is shown to be wise and loving, the adventurous baby bird as being young and impetuous, like most young boys. Besides, the worm is *also* portrayed as a Southern black. But as far as the dialect, all of the characters *including the fox* are simply speaking in a Southern dialect.
The plot is well written and portrays both forgiveness (on the part of the worm) and good parenting (on the part of the mother bird.)
Historically, all races are charicatured in cartoons, white (*especially* whites!), blacks, Eastern Asians, native Americans, etc. Learn to have a sense of humor and just view this cartoon for what it is… HUMOR and entertainment. Don’t be too sensitive. I.e. dont’t become somebody who falls for Jerry Seinfeld’s “anti-dentite” skit.
I enjoyed this cartoon as a child and *still* enjoy it. Overcome a tendency to write this one off as “racist” and simply enjoy it.

]]> By: berberry http://cartoon-place.com/merrie-melodies-early-worm-gets-bird/#comment-402 berberry Fri, 25 Mar 2005 16:54:39 +0000 http://cartoon-place.com/?p=485#comment-402 I have mixed emotions about this cartoon. It's classic Warners animation, but here we have a family of blackbirds, voiced by whites mimicking an African-American dialect. It should be no surprise that many will find this piece to be highly offensive, as I did. On the other hand, I also feel that this film is a part of American history and is reflective of the time in which it was made. Many young people today don't realize that this sort of mockery of blacks was once quite common and even institutionalized. Perhaps this cartoon can help some folks to a greater understanding of our history as a people. All things condidered, I decided on a mid-level star rating for this short cartoon picture. I have mixed emotions about this cartoon. It’s classic Warners animation, but here we have a family of blackbirds, voiced by whites mimicking an African-American dialect. It should be no surprise that many will find this piece to be highly offensive, as I did.

On the other hand, I also feel that this film is a part of American history and is reflective of the time in which it was made. Many young people today don’t realize that this sort of mockery of blacks was once quite common and even institutionalized. Perhaps this cartoon can help some folks to a greater understanding of our history as a people.

All things condidered, I decided on a mid-level star rating for this short cartoon picture.

]]>